How We Calculate Suggested Salaries

Every MLS free agent and option player on this site gets a suggested salary for the next season: a model estimate of what a new contract would pay, shown as a range with a confidence label. It combines two seasons of MLS stats, the player’s age and position, and his current contract. Tested on 195 real contracts signed between the 2025 and 2026 seasons, its errors were about 36% smaller than simply assuming each player kept his current pay.

What the suggested salary is, and what it is not

The suggested salary is the guaranteed compensation a player would most likely earn next season if he signed a new MLS contract. Guaranteed compensation is the MLS Players Association’s measure: base salary plus signing and guaranteed bonuses, spread across the years of the contract. It is the same figure we show for every player’s current pay.

It is an estimate, not reporting. It does not know what clubs and agents are discussing, whether a player wants to leave MLS, what transfer fee a club would pay, or how many clubs want him. Treat it as a fair starting point for the conversation, the way a scout or a fan would reason about value from the numbers.

You will find it on every free agent’s and option player’s page, on the Free Agency page, and in each club’s Free Agency Watch.

The data behind it

Four sources, each used for what it does best.

  • MLS Players Association salary guide: every player’s current guaranteed compensation and base salary (updated November 19, 2026).
  • MLS official statistics: regular-season minutes, starts, appearances, goals and assists for the last two seasons, across every MLS club a player played for.
  • API-Football: match ratings, and the matches each player missed through injury, suspension or international duty.
  • Our roster and contract records: contract end year, option years, roster designation (Designated Player, TAM, U22, Homegrown) and detailed position.

Playoff matches are left out, so every player is judged on the same 34-match regular season. When two sources disagree on minutes or goals, MLS’s official numbers win.

How it works, in five steps

  1. Role. Minutes and starts are measured against the matches a player was available for, not every match his club played. A starter who missed 10 games injured keeps a starter’s role. A fit player with the same minutes is a rotation player. We never treat an injured player as benched.
  2. Quality. Each season’s match rating is compared with players at the same position in the same season, and expressed as how far above or below a regular starter he played. Ratings differ by position and by season, so this keeps a full-back from being judged against attacking midfielders. Attackers also get credit for goals plus assists per 90 minutes. Seasons with few minutes count for less, and the newer season counts for 60%.
  3. Market estimate. We start from what a regular starter at his position earns at peak age, add 8% for a season of pay growth and 15% because new contracts price above existing ones, then scale it for his role, his quality (about 15% more per standard deviation above a regular starter), his scoring if he is an attacker, and his age.
  4. Contract anchor. His current salary carries information stats cannot see: reputation, pedigree, leverage. We move it forward one season (contracts that ran on grew a median 8% a year), then adjust it for his age and for how he played relative to what that pay level usually buys.
  5. Blend. The suggestion combines the market estimate and the contract anchor. For players aged 25 to 29 the contract counts for a little over half. Younger and older players lean more on the market, and players paid far above the market, such as big TAM deals, lean mostly on their contract.

Starting points: a regular starter’s pay by position

2026 guaranteed compensation for a prime-age regular starter who is not a Designated Player or U22 signing. From the median pay of starters aged 25 to 31, before the growth and new-contract steps.

PositionStarter’s pay
Attacking midfielder$900,000
Winger$900,000
Centre-forward$800,000
Defensive midfielder$720,000
Central midfielder$720,000
Centre-back$660,000
Full-back$580,000
Goalkeeper$480,000

How age changes the estimate

Multiplier on the market estimate, by age next season. Goalkeepers follow the same curve three years later, centre-backs one year later.

Age next seasonMultiplier
221.06
241.03
26 to 291.00
300.97
310.92
320.87
330.82
340.72
350.62
360.50

Special cases

  • Players coming off small deals. A player earning $200,000 or less, aged 30 or under next season, is priced on the market rather than his old salary. In real deals, regular starters coming off contracts that size re-signed for a median of about $570,000, so a regular starter’s suggestion usually sits between $350,000 and $750,000.
  • Young players who already contribute. Players under 24 who play a real role and rate well for their age get a potential premium, largest for teenagers. An ordinary young regular stays in the normal range.
  • Long or repeated absences. A 5% trim applies only when a player missed at least 40% of last season’s matches, or more than a third in both seasons. Missed matches include suspensions and international duty, so the bar is high.
  • No minutes. A player on a roster with no MLS minutes in two seasons is priced as a reserve.

The range and the confidence label

  • High: two seasons of stats, at least 1,800 minutes, and a full record of missed matches. Never used for players 34 or older next season.
  • Medium: at least one season and 900 minutes.
  • Low: fewer minutes, a Designated Player, or a salary far above the market for his position.

The lower the confidence, the wider the range. In testing, about two in three real contracts landed inside a medium-confidence range.

The value check on club options

When a club holds an option on a player, we compare the suggested salary with what he earns now, since the option year usually pays about the same.

  • Good value: the suggested salary is at least 95% of his current pay.
  • Close call: between 75% and 95%.
  • Costly: below 75%.

This is a read on value, not a prediction of the club’s decision. Clubs also weigh roster slots, the cap, depth at the position and what the market offers.

How well it works

Tested on the 195 players who signed a new deal or an extension between the January 2025 and 2026 salary data, Designated Players excluded.

MethodTypical error
Our suggested salary0.47
Market estimate alone0.59
Current contract alone, adjusted0.66
Current pay plus 8% growth0.74

Typical error is the root-mean-square error on a log scale, which treats guessing double and guessing half as equally wrong. Lower is better. On the same 195 deals, 46% of suggestions landed within 25% of the real figure, and 63% of real deals landed inside our range. The middle of our misses was 6% on the low side.

It is most accurate for players aged 30 to 32, where 60% landed within 25%, and least accurate for players 23 and younger, whose next deals vary most.

Two caveats. We used these same deals to tune the model, so this is a check of fit rather than a fully independent test. And these players had one season of stats before signing; this winter’s free agents have two, which should help.

Where it is weakest

  • Designated Players and big transfer signings. These deals are negotiated one by one around transfer fees and marketing value. We show a number, marked low confidence.
  • Players returning from long injuries, whose last full season says more than their recent minutes.
  • Mid-season arrivals with only a few months of MLS data.
  • Players likely to leave MLS, whose next contract is set by another league’s market.

Our other numbers

  • Production Index ranks players against others at the same position, across attacking, passing and defending, weighted by what each position is asked to do.
  • Best Value compares a player’s minutes-weighted match rating with his guaranteed compensation, so it rewards players who perform well on modest pay.
  • Salary Rules explains the cap, minimum salaries, Designated Players and allocation money, with sources.