Red Bull New York

John McCarthy Salary & Contract

Goalkeeper · #77 · 34 yrs · USA · 6' 1" · Option ends 2027

John McCarthy is a 34-year-old goalkeeper for Red Bull New York who earns $589,167 in 2026 guaranteed compensation (MLSPA, November 19, 2026). Red Bull New York holds a club option on his contract for 2027. Our model values him at about $340,000 for 2027, so our value check rates the option as costly.

Rating
—
Guaranteed Comp
$589,167
Best Value Rank
—
Production Index
—

Suggested 2027 Salary

Red Bull New York holds a club option on his contract for 2027. This is what the model thinks he is worth on a new deal, to set against keeping him on the option. Not a prediction of the club's decision.

Suggested next-contract value

$340,000

medium confidence range $245,000 to $475,000

down 42% on his current $589,167

Value check on the option: Costly

$0dashed = current $589,167$630,000
  • 2025: 1,080 minutes, 12 starts over 34 matches, no listed absences: role 51%.
  • Match ratings in 2025 put him in the bottom 1% of regular goalkeepers (−18% vs. an average starter).
  • Age 35 next season: ×0.87 on a prime-age starting goalkeeper baseline of $596,160.
  • 32% anchored on his current $589,167 (league pay growth +8%, age ×0.87, performance −18% vs. what that salary usually buys, role −5%) = $431,483; the rest is the position-market estimate of $304,881.

Stats: MLS official regular-season stats (minutes, starts, goals, assists), with match ratings and absences from API-Football, last two seasons, as of Nov 16, 2026. Salary: MLSPA salary guide, updated November 19, 2026 (guaranteed compensation). How this is calculated · All free agents and options

John McCarthy 2026 Season Stats

No qualifying minutes yet this season.

Season Stats
—
Not enough minutes played yet this season to have a full stat line.

Last two MLS seasons

SeasonMinutesStartsAppsRatingGoalsAssistsUnavailable
20251,08012126.48000

Regular season, all MLS clubs combined. "Unavailable" counts matches missed through injury, suspension or international duty. Source: MLS official regular-season stats (minutes, starts, goals, assists), with match ratings and absences from API-Football.

John McCarthy Production Index

Percentile vs. other qualifying goalkeepers at the same position, weighted the way Production Index weights that position. See the full ranking →

Not enough qualifying minutes yet this season for a Production Index score.

Similar Players

Closest season-long profile among qualifying goalkeepers — production pillars and season output both weighted in. Compare each one's own guaranteed comp to gauge value.

Not enough qualifying minutes yet this season to find comparable players.

John McCarthy's 2026 Salary & Contract

MLSPA salary guide (updated November 19, 2026), guaranteed compensation.

Base Salary
$525,000
Guaranteed Compensation
$589,167

John McCarthy Roster Designation (DP, U22, Homegrown)

MLS cap mechanics (Designated Player / TAM / U22 Initiative / Homegrown / Generation Adidas, contract length, options) — a secondary source to the MLSPA guide above.

Senior minimum roster spot (no special designation)
Roster Status
Senior
International Slot
No
Contract Through
2026
Option Years
2027, 2028
Acquired From
Trade from LAG
202520262027202820292030
$589,167$589,167$589,167$589,167$0$0